The challenge
Acquisition cost was high and rising, and response rates were falling. The team mailed broad prospect lists and had no way to predict how likely an individual prospect was to respond.
What Squark did
- Applied Squark response models to the prospect pools.
- Ranked prospects by their predicted cost to acquire.
- Put the top prospects first in line for mail, and removed the weakest names from the lists.
- Showed which prospect characteristics predicted response.
The results
Cost to acquire a donor fell 7% across the program, and by as much as 50% in the highest-propensity segments. Mail volume came down without a matching loss of new donors.
What to take from it
The weakest names on a list cost as much to mail as the best ones. Removing them gives up few new donors and saves the mail that would have gone to them.
The organization is not named here. These are the results of one organization's program. Yours will depend on your donor file, your offers and your channels.